Blog

How long to keep hotel time and payroll records

· payroll, recordkeeping, time & attendance

There are two federal clocks, not one. Payroll records are preserved for three years; the basic time cards and rate tables the payroll was computed from are preserved for two (29 CFR 516.5, 29 CFR 516.6).

The second number is the trap. A wage claim under the FLSA generally reaches back two years, and three where the violation is found willful (29 U.S.C. § 255(a)). So a property that deletes punch detail at exactly twenty-four months, doing precisely what the regulation asks, can destroy the only evidence it has about a year that somebody is still entitled to sue over. The practical answer for a small hotel is one retention period rather than two, set to the longest clock that touches you — and for most properties that is neither three years nor two.

How long to keep payroll records, bucket by bucket

RecordPeriodCounted from
Payroll records containing the required employee data3 yearsLast date of entry
Collective bargaining agreements, certificates, notices3 yearsLast effective date
Sales and purchase records — total dollar volume of business, total goods purchased3 yearsThe periods the employer keeps in the ordinary course of business
Basic time and earning cards or sheets showing daily starting and stopping times2 yearsDate of last entry
Wage rate tables and schedules used to compute straight-time or overtime pay2 yearsLast effective date

The phrase that matters in the fourth row is the regulation’s own: the daily starting and stopping time of individual employees. That is your punch data. It sits in the shorter bucket, and it is the single most useful thing you own when an old week is questioned, because the payroll register tells you a housekeeper was paid for 38.5 hours in a week and says nothing whatsoever about which hours those were.

Why two years is the wrong policy at a hotel

Work the dates and the gap is obvious.

Say a former housekeeper at an invented 54-room motel files a claim on 1 March 2027, covering hours from autumn 2024 onward, and pleads it as willful. Willfulness is not a word a plaintiff gets for free — the Supreme Court’s test in McLaughlin v. Richland Shoe Co. (1988) requires that the employer knew its conduct was prohibited or showed reckless disregard for whether it was — but whether it applies is decided long after the records question is settled.

  • Non-willful reach: back to 1 March 2025.
  • Willful reach: back to 1 March 2024.

A clean two-year purge run on 1 March 2027 deletes every time card before 1 March 2025. That is the entire first year of the window the claim is actually asking about. The payroll registers survive — they are in the three-year bucket — so the motel can prove what it paid and cannot show what was worked. And when the employer’s own record is thin, the employee’s recollection carries far more weight than operators expect; that asymmetry is the whole subject of a schedule is not a time record, and it is the reason the cheap half of this problem is worth fixing before the expensive half arrives.

If your punch history currently lives somewhere you cannot query by person and week, start a free trial and run one real week through it, so you can see what a retrievable record looks like before you need one.

The other clocks, and they run longer

Federal wage-and-hour rules are not the only retention requirement pointed at the same filing cabinet.

  • Tax. Employment tax records are kept at least four years after the tax becomes due or is paid, whichever is later (IRS Topic no. 305). That is already longer than either FLSA bucket.
  • State. The periods differ, and the differences are not small. New York is commonly cited at six years for payroll records under its Labor Law. California is a good illustration of why you should not trust a chart: write-ups disagree, some giving three years and others four. Look yours up at the state agency, for every state you operate in.
  • In a portfolio, the longest wins. Two motels in two states inherit the longer of the two periods in practice, because a single retention setting applied across both properties is the only one anybody will actually follow.

Netting that out takes one step more than it looks, because the clocks do not all start in the same place. The FLSA buckets run from the record — the last date of entry. The tax clock runs from when the tax became due or was paid, which for a given year is during that year and into the following one. So four years from the record is not four years of tax cover; it can lapse up to about a year early. A single property that keeps everything for five years, counted from the end of the year the record belongs to, clears both FLSA buckets with margin and clears the tax minimum on either reading of when that clock starts. Add a New York property and the number is six. Neither figure is a rule anybody published — they are the arithmetic of overlapping rules, which is the only form the question ever reaches an owner in.

“In what form” is the half nobody plans for

The regulation says preserve. It does not say preserve in a form that can find anything, so a shoebox of signed paper satisfies the letter and fails the first time you need one week out of it. Four tests, in order of how often they are failed:

  1. Can you produce the daily start and stop times for one named person, for one week twenty months ago, in under ten minutes? If the honest answer is “we would rebuild it from the schedule”, you do not have a time record for that week.
  2. If a punch was changed, does the record show what it was before, who changed it, and when? An edit with no history is indistinguishable from a fabrication, and the edits that matter are the small ones. ProfitClock keeps punch edits append-only for this reason, and records every punch against the property’s own local date so a late shift does not migrate to the wrong day.
  3. Is the day on the record the hotel’s day? A night auditor’s 1:30 AM punch filed under yesterday or tomorrow is a record of something that did not happen.
  4. Do you still have it after you stop paying whoever holds it? Export before you cancel, not after — switching time clock systems covers that sequence.

Photos are the one place to go shorter rather than longer. An image of a person at work carries privacy weight that a timesheet does not, so set that window deliberately and separately, and ask what your state expects of it.

A retention policy that fits on one page

  • One period for everything, set to the longest rule that applies to your states and counted from the end of the year the record belongs to. Two numbers invite the wrong one.
  • Written down, dated, and naming who runs the deletions. An undocumented practice is not a policy.
  • Exported once a year to something you own, not only to something you rent monthly.
  • Deletions on a calendar, not when a drive fills up or a contract lapses. The purge that causes the damage is always the one nobody decided to run.

Where this is genuinely hard, and where we are not the answer

Nobody can hand you the right number without knowing which states you operate in, how your entities file, and whether an open claim has already frozen a period. Software does not make you compliant; it makes a record retrievable, which is a smaller and more honest claim. The period itself gets decided by a person who looked it up, and only then enforced by whatever system holds the data.

This is not legal advice, and nothing above is a substitute for the rules that apply to you. Retention periods vary by state and by record type and they change. Confirm each one with your state labor agency and the current regulation text, and get an employment lawyer involved before you set or shorten a retention period. The summary of the federal regulations, the statute of limitations and the case cited here is based on secondary sources rather than on the primary text, and should be checked against the regulation and the statute themselves.

Start seeing what labor actually costs

Set up your property, put staff on the clock, and read tomorrow morning’s labor number.

14-day free trial · No credit card · Cancel anytime