Blog

Per-employee or per-room: pricing a hotel time clock

· buying, pricing, time & attendance

A time clock quote contains two numbers and only one is printed. The sticker price says what this month costs. The pricing model — per employee, per location, or per room — says what the bill does over the next three years as you add a summer housekeeper, split a front desk shift and replace six positions. In the worked example below, a mid-range per-user meter and per-room billing land within about $340 of each other over a year, while the per-user column alone doubles — $684 to $1,368 — purely on the rate you happen to be quoted. So the rate decides this month’s price and the model decides what the price tracks for as long as you keep the system: choose on how the model behaves, not on which quote looks cheapest in January.

We price per room, which puts us inside this comparison rather than above it — and is why the section on where per-room pricing is wrong names us specifically.

Three meters, and what each is counting

Per active user. A few dollars a month for every person in the system. It counts people, so it moves when your roster moves — every spring, every autumn, and every time someone quits mid-week.

Flat per location. One price per property, whatever the headcount. The meter counts nothing, which makes it predictable and indifferent to whether the property is 18 rooms or 90. It gets no row in the table below because a flat fee’s year is simply the quoted monthly price times twelve, so there is no arithmetic to show, and per-location tiers tend to be gated by features rather than by headcount, so they do not line up with the two metered rows. Compare whatever flat number you are quoted against the two meters we can compute.

Per room. A base fee covering a first block of rooms, then a per-room rate, usually declining as the count rises. It meters the one thing about a hotel that does not change without a construction permit.

Each is defensible. They fail differently, and the failure that matters is the one your property’s shape walks into.

One motel, three meters

Take an invented 44-room independent in Ohio — breakfast service, in-house laundry, no restaurant. Twelve people on payroll September through April; eighteen from May through August, adding two housekeepers, a laundry hand, two part-time front desk and one breakfast. Six positions turn over in the year, each replacement overlapping the leaver by about two weeks of training.

That is 12 × 8 + 18 × 4 = 168 person-months, plus roughly three more from the training overlaps: 171 billable person-months if the meter counts anyone active.

The per-user rates below are illustrative — $4, $6 and $8 per active user per month — not any vendor’s quote. Put your own quote in and the shape holds.

MeterA January monthA July monthFull year
$4 per active user$48$72$684
$6 per active user$72$108$1,026
$8 per active user$96$144$1,368
Per room, 44 rooms, monthly billing$107$107$1,284
Per room, 44 rooms, annual billing$85.60$85.60$1,027

The per-room rows are our own published Core bands at 44 rooms: a $69 base covering the first 28 rooms, then $2.50 for rooms 29–40 and $2.00 for rooms 41–44, with annual billing applying the same shape at roughly 20% less. The $2.00 band runs to room 80; here it covers the last four. The full bands and a room-count calculator are on the pricing page.

So what does the arithmetic say? At $4 per user the meter wins by about $340 a year against annual per-room billing. At $6 it is a dead heat — $1,026 against $1,027, which is close enough to be noise. At $8 the room-based bill is cheaper by about $340. Anyone telling you one model is structurally cheaper for a 44-room motel is quoting a rate, not a model.

Two caveats on our own table. A per-user quote can carry a minimum seat count and an annual commitment, either of which would raise the low end, so ask; and a leaner roster — eight year-round rather than twelve — moves the per-user column down faster than any other row here.

The part the table cannot price

The arithmetic is a wash. The incentives are not, and this is the whole argument.

A time and attendance system has one requirement everything else depends on: every person who works a shift is on it. The weekend helper covering two desk shifts a month. The laundry hand who comes in for four hours on turnover days. If each of those carries a visible line on next month’s invoice, the cheapest way to handle the four-hour laundry hand is to leave them off the system and write the hours on paper — and hours written on paper are precisely the hours that become an argument nine months later, when nobody can reconstruct them.

That is not a prediction about any vendor’s behaviour; it is an incentive the model creates for the buyer, and buyers act on incentives in small ways they never consciously decide.

The honest counter, and the strongest thing that can be said for per-user pricing: at a seasonal hotel a bill that rises in July rises in the month revenue is highest, so a meter tracking your staffing tracks your business. If your off-season is genuinely lean — a property down to four people in February — the per-user column is not just cheaper, it is cheaper in the month you feel it.

Five questions about the meter

Ask these of any per-user or per-location quote before signing. None can be answered persuasively in the abstract, which is what makes them useful.

  1. What counts as a billable user — anyone with a profile, anyone who punched this month, or anyone marked active? The three bill the same roster differently.
  2. When does a leaver stop billing? The day you deactivate, the end of the month, or the end of the term you committed to?
  3. Does a returning seasonal hire cost a new seat, and does their punch history return with them? If last summer’s housekeeper comes back as a fresh record, your year-over-year comparison quietly resets.
  4. What is a location? A motel with two buildings and one front desk is one property to you; confirm it is one to the invoice.
  5. What is the minimum, and what does renewal price off — current headcount or peak? A renewal priced off August is a different product.

Where per-room pricing is the wrong model, ours included

Per-room pricing assumes labor scales with rooms. At a rooms-only motel it broadly does: more rooms, more cleans, more coverage.

It stops being true at extended-stay and low-service shapes. Take an 80-room extended-stay with weekly housekeeping and six on payroll. Our own Core bands put that property at $179 a month — the $69 base, then $2.50 for rooms 29–40 and $2.00 for rooms 41–80. A $6-per-user meter puts the same property at $36. We are roughly five times the price for that shape, and no feature list closes a gap that size. If your room count is high and your payroll is small, per-room pricing is the expensive model and we are not the right purchase.

The mirror case is where per-room pricing wins, and our own bands are the clearest way to show it. A 30-room property with a restaurant and twenty-five staff pays a per-user meter for all twenty-five — $150 a month at the $6 rate — against $74 on our Core bands, the $69 base plus two rooms at $2.50. Where staff outnumber rooms the room-based meter is the cheap one, by a factor of two here, and a flat quote has to beat $74 to win on price. What a flat fee sells there is predictability, not a lower number.

The order to do this in

Decide which model fits your property’s shape, use the questions above to find out what the meter really counts, and compare monthly figures last. The whole table spans about $680 a year, which is small next to the administrative hours a time system is bought to remove — those hours are worked through in does a 40-room hotel need labor management software, and they, not the subscription, decide whether to buy anything at all. If you are still mapping the category, what hotel scheduling and labor software costs has the ranges by vendor type and what to check before buying hotel time clock software covers the nine things a demo will not show you.

Start seeing what labor actually costs

Set up your property, put staff on the clock, and read tomorrow morning’s labor number.

14-day free trial · No credit card · Cancel anytime