Blog

Overtime vs. hiring a part-timer: where it flips

· overtime, labor cost, scheduling

For most hotels, covering a recurring gap with overtime is cheaper below about three to four hours a week, and a part-time hire is cheaper above that. Overtime costs 1.5 times the regular rate for every hour past 40 in the workweek, and a part-timer costs a straight rate plus a fixed cost to find, train and keep them. The flip point is where those two lines cross. Below, the crossing is worked out on an invented property with placeholder numbers, so you can swap in your own and find yours.

The two costs, written out

Overtime is the simpler one. Under the federal FLSA, hours over 40 in a workweek are paid at 1.5 times the regular rate for non-exempt employees. Some states add daily overtime on top, which changes the math, so check your state’s rule. Every overtime hour costs the base wage times 1.5, plus whatever payroll burden rides on wages (employer payroll taxes, workers’ compensation, and so on).

A part-timer has three costs overtime does not:

  1. A straight-time wage, which is lower per hour than overtime.
  2. A fixed cost to get them productive: posting the job, interviewing, paperwork, and the paid hours they spend shadowing before they work alone.
  3. A minimum shift. Nobody drives to a motel for a ninety-minute shift. If the shortest shift you can realistically offer is four hours, then a three-hour gap costs four hours of pay.

The invented property

A 36-room interior-corridor inn outside a mid-sized Ohio town (invented). Its front desk runs on two full-timers who each sit at exactly 40 hours. The weekend evening gap, a few hours that keeps landing on one of them, goes to overtime. Placeholder numbers throughout:

  • Regular rate: $16/hr (placeholder)
  • Overtime rate: $16 x 1.5 = $24/hr
  • Burden on wages: 12% (placeholder; use your own payroll-tax and insurance load)
  • Part-timer wage: $15/hr (placeholder)
  • One-time cost to bring a part-timer on: $500 (placeholder: a posted ad, an hour of interviewing, paperwork, and six paid shadow hours)
  • Minimum shift: 4 hours

Loaded hourly costs:

Overtime hourPart-timer hour
Wage$24.00$15.00
Burden at 12%$2.88$1.80
Loaded cost per hour$26.88$16.80

Per hour, the part-timer is $10.08 cheaper. That is the margin the fixed cost has to be paid back from.

How many weeks do you amortize the fixed cost over?

This is the assumption that moves the answer most, and it is a guess about turnover. Hotel part-timers leave. If you expect a typical part-timer to stay 26 weeks, the $500 is $19.23 a week. If you expect 13 weeks, it is $38.46 a week.

Here is the weekly bill for a recurring gap of H hours, at 26 weeks:

Gap per weekOvertime costPart-timer costCheaper
2 hours$53.76$86.43Overtime
3 hours$80.64$86.43Overtime
4 hours$107.52$86.43Part-timer
6 hours$161.28$120.03Part-timer

The part-timer column for 2, 3 and 4 hours is the same $86.43 because of the four-hour minimum: four hours at $16.80 is $67.20, plus the $19.23 weekly share of the hiring cost. At six hours it is 6 x $16.80 = $100.80, plus $19.23, or $120.03.

The break-even is where $86.43 equals H x $26.88, so H is about 3.2 hours a week. If you only expect the hire to last 13 weeks, the fixed share doubles to $38.46, the part-timer’s four-hour week costs $105.66, and the break-even moves to about 3.9 hours.

Neither answer is a rule. The point is the shape: a small recurring gap is not worth a hire, and a gap that is consistently half a shift or more is.

Where the simple version breaks

The gap has to be recurring and fillable. The table assumes the same four hours turn up every week, on a day someone can actually work. A gap that is eight hours one week and zero the next is not a part-timer’s schedule. That is a pool of people willing to pick up extra shifts, which is a different arrangement.

The overtime has to be real overtime. If the person picking up the gap is at 32 hours that week, the hours cost $16, not $24, and the question disappears. The comparison above only applies to people already at 40. Shift swaps are a common way people end up at 40 without anyone planning it.

It ignores what overtime does to the person. An employee who works 44 hours every week is also the employee who calls out in month four. That cost is real but it has no number in this post, and I would rather say so than invent one.

It ignores what the part-timer might cost beyond wages. If you offer benefits, there is usually an hours threshold that triggers eligibility, and a part-timer who drifts past it changes the arithmetic. Check your own plan documents, and your state’s rules, before assuming a part-timer is wage-only.

It ignores the second gap. A new part-timer also needs coverage when they call out, and you now have one more person to schedule. For a five- or six-person desk, that is a small cost. For a team of two, a third person solves more than the four hours.

How to run it on your own property

  1. Pull the last eight weeks of hours by person. Count how many overtime hours were worked and on what day and shift.
  2. Group them: does the same shift keep generating the same overtime? That recurring slice is your H.
  3. Compute your loaded overtime rate: wage x 1.5 x (1 + burden).
  4. Compute the part-timer’s weekly cost: the larger of (minimum shift, H) times their loaded rate, plus the hiring cost divided by your honest guess at how many weeks they stay.
  5. Compare. If they are close, keep the overtime and revisit in a quarter. Hiring is easier to start than to undo.

If you want the overtime hours by person and by day without building the sheet yourself, start a free trial and run a week of punches through it. Then check the result against the overtime calculator, because the number you act on should be one you could recompute by hand.

What this does not tell you

Whether you can hire at all is a separate problem in a thin labor market, and the gap may be unfillable at $15. It also does not say whether the hours should exist: if the gap is a quiet stretch where one fewer person would do, sending people home early removes the cost instead of moving it. Settle that first.

Start seeing what labor actually costs

Set up your property, put staff on the clock, and read tomorrow morning’s labor number.

14-day free trial · No credit card · Cancel anytime